I usually don't use the glue pad, they can't get out once they go in....and if they do get caught on a glue trap, I just bop them in the head and kill them.
Here's what I use. Works either with bait or without!
https://www.walmart.com/ip/Catchmaster-Reusable-Multi-Catch-Mouse-Trap-Easy-Ready-to-Use-Indoors-Outdoors-Child-Pet-Safe-Free-Glue-Board-Included/49211722?athbdg=L1600&from=/search